The red-cell ledger#
This page lists every red verdict that a registered study publishes. It names the roadmap ask that
owns each one. python -m tests.studies.evidence.red_cells writes each table from the committed
results. tests/unit/test_red_cell_ledger.py checks each table against those results.
What counts as red#
A study publishes three kinds of verdict, and a fourth kind of row when a comparator fit failed. The ledger reads each kind the way the regeneration gates it.
kind |
source file |
red when |
|---|---|---|
truth |
|
the row fails its truth gate. The ledger skips a comparator row when the study declares an accepted reference failure |
paired |
|
the paired conclusion is not |
property |
|
the cell fails its own rule or the joint clause of its family. A |
accounting |
|
a hook audit fails after the recorded comparator failures are counted. A truth or paired cell that its accounting turns red stays a truth or paired row, and its “fails by” names the accounting |
The ledger reads each verdict column as a boolean. It refuses a table whose verdict column holds
a blank or any other value, because a blank would otherwise read as a pass. The paired
reference_valid column repeats the comparator’s truth row, so the truth kind covers it.
The ledger reads verdict rows and accounting rows only. Six study modules also define a scientific_failures hook.
The regeneration adds each hook’s rows to the failures it gates or reports. These hooks audit
fits and publish no verdict cell, so the ledger does not read them.
study |
policy |
what the hook reports |
what holds its result |
|---|---|---|---|
|
the score audit of both implementations, and the solver flag of |
the study page and |
|
|
the same two audits |
the study page and |
|
|
the exact-equality probe of the scale workaround |
|
|
|
the exact-equality probe of the scale workaround on both R paths |
|
|
|
the same probe |
|
|
|
the replay gates that failed: R’s selection replayed in |
the study page and |
tests/unit/test_red_cell_ledger.py fails when a study module defines a hook that this table
does not list.
Who owns each red row#
Each owner is an id in the Red-cell owners table of the
roadmap.
F18 and
F19 wait on a
published result, or on a natural extension that meets the
Eligibility conditions.
F27 owns the two
truth rows of the learned-rule boundary study. Its table states
that the exceptional row has no published result and that the weak_blip row has one. Each
RM18- owner holds cells that a declared diagnostic read once. Its acceptance cell gives the
reading and the declaration that a future regeneration needs.
The X41-negative-control owner holds the three misspecification_control cells of the
sequential baselines study. They are a declared negative control. The
study lists them as red before the run, and no work is owed.
A red row stays red under the reporting policy. It is read again only under the condition its
owner names. The ledger moves no margin and changes no verdict.
Every F18 row measures a working-mechanism plug-in diagnostic. The package does not publish that
diagnostic as inference: the greedy, ordered, and discrete C-TMLE paths refuse ci, pvalue, and
std_error. The cells keep their std_error, ci_lower, ci_upper, and covered columns, and
those columns now read plugin_std_error and plugin_interval. The two accessors call the same
body the refused ones call, so the reframing changed no number and no study was regenerated. Read a
red F18 coverage cell as a measurement of a diagnostic, and not as a refused coverage claim.
The two red F19 generated-design cells likewise measure plugin_std_error and
plugin_interval for the shipped joint outcome-adaptive fit. Their coverage and SE-ratio numbers
remain evidence about that diagnostic, not an inference claim. F19 needs a result for the exact
shared-multinomial, jointly targeted construction before those cells can support one.
The test fails on four states.
state |
why the test refuses it |
|---|---|
a red row with no owner |
nobody is on record to close it |
an owner entry with no red row |
the entry describes a verdict that is no longer red |
an owner that the roadmap |
the owner points at no ask |
a red row in a study registered as |
a |
owner |
red rows |
studies |
|---|---|---|
12 |
selector-based point-treatment C-TMLE, selector-based multi-arm C-TMLE, C-TMLE candidate sequences |
|
90 |
outcome-adaptive multi-arm C-TMLE, outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE, outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
|
2 |
CV-TMLE of the fold-local learned-rule value at exceptional and weak-blip laws |
|
2 |
cross-fitted weighted end-of-study longitudinal TMLE |
|
8 |
selector-based multi-arm C-TMLE, DR-TMLE for binary complete data, multi-arm point-treatment DR-TMLE, cross-fitted weighted end-of-study longitudinal TMLE |
|
3 |
DR-TMLE for binary complete data, multi-arm point-treatment DR-TMLE |
|
6 |
ordinary weighted end-of-study longitudinal TMLE |
|
1 |
ordinary continuous modified treatment policies |
|
5 |
ordinary point-treatment TMLE with baseline strata |
|
6 |
clustered cross-fitted end-of-study longitudinal TMLE, sequentially doubly robust longitudinal estimation, ordinary survival-curve longitudinal TMLE, default simultaneous bands across shipped fit shapes |
|
2 |
randomized multi-arm missing-outcome DR-TMLE |
|
2 |
observational missing-data DR-TMLE with a composite indicator |
|
1 |
sequentially doubly robust longitudinal estimation |
|
2 |
stratified incremental and MSM targeting |
|
2 |
identity-link MSM with baseline strata |
|
4 |
DR-TMLE with baseline strata |
|
3 |
DR-TMLE with baseline strata |
|
1 |
C-TMLE candidate sequences |
|
1 |
ordinary known stochastic categorical longitudinal TMLE |
|
1 |
longitudinal modified treatment policies |
|
1 |
ordinary point modified treatment policies |
|
1 |
longitudinal incremental propensity-score interventions under dropout |
|
2 |
point-treatment survival, cross-fitted point-treatment survival |
|
1 |
parametric g-formula |
|
9 |
clustered point-treatment CV-TMLE at unequal cluster sizes, clustered TMLE intervals on a t reference at few clusters |
|
4 |
boundary-binding price plans over follow-up lengths |
|
3 |
boundary-binding price plans over follow-up lengths |
|
1 |
modified treatment policies at declared boundaries |
|
3 |
full-refit bootstrap and derived contrasts |
|
3 |
sequential g-computation and IPW |
|
total |
182 |
35 studies |
The red rows#
The “measured” column gives the endpoints that the failed verdict reads. A property row uses the same text as the “measured” column of its study page.
study |
kind |
row |
role |
fails by |
measured |
owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
truth |
|
cleverly-stratified-tmle |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0027 to 0.000813, coverage 0.9170, SE ratio 0.9850 |
||
truth |
|
tmle3-stratified |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0027 to 0.000813, coverage 0.9170, SE ratio 0.9849 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9056 to 0.9344, SE ratio 0.9315 to 1.0094, empirical efficiency ratio 0.9753 to 1.0552, reported efficiency ratio 0.9742 to 0.9931 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
joint coverage 0.9038 to 0.9329 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
joint coverage 0.8881 to 0.9194 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9283 to 0.9555, SE ratio 0.9273 to 1.0105 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9289 to 0.9560, SE ratio 0.7818 to 0.9387 |
||
paired |
|
paired |
inconclusive: calibration leg |
difference -0.000049 to 0.000037 within 0.000694, RMSE ratio bound 1.0047 vs 1.1000, coverage difference bound -0.0220 vs -0.0250, calibration excess bound 0.0523 vs 0.0500, resolution 0.0476 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9233 to 0.9515, SE ratio 0.9264 to 1.0042, empirical efficiency ratio 0.9925 to 1.0766, reported efficiency ratio 0.9937 to 1.0005 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-stratified-drtmle |
its truth gate |
bias 0.0023 to 0.0112, coverage 0.9000, SE ratio 0.9388 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-stratified |
its truth gate |
bias 0.0022 to 0.0111, coverage 0.8925, SE ratio 0.9205 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0136 to 0.0185, margin 0.0067, SE ratio 0.9902 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0094 to 0.0162, margin 0.0093, SE ratio 0.9505 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0123 to 0.0214, margin 0.0124, SE ratio 0.9364 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0179 to 0.0286, margin 0.0147, SE ratio 1.0627 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9069 to 0.9380, SE ratio 0.9294 to 1.0112, empirical efficiency ratio 1.0348 to 1.1237, reported efficiency ratio 1.0296 to 1.0653 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9182 to 0.9450, SE ratio 0.9453 to 1.0187, paired coverage gain 0.4021 to 0.4542 |
||
property |
|
control |
the family’s joint clause |
coverage 0.4781 to 0.5310, SE ratio 0.3326 to 0.3580, paired coverage gain 0.4021 to 0.4542 |
||
property |
|
control |
its own rule |
bias -0.0013 to 0.0105, coverage 0.8874 to 0.9121, SE ratio 0.8499 to 1.0008 |
||
property |
|
control |
its own rule |
bias -0.000551 to 0.0077, coverage 0.8646 to 0.8915, SE ratio 0.8119 to 0.9042 |
||
property |
|
control |
its own rule |
bias -0.0011 to 0.0057, coverage 0.8531 to 0.8810, SE ratio 0.7967 to 0.8764 |
||
property |
|
control |
its own rule |
bias 0.0242 to 0.0394, coverage 0.8049 to 0.8363, SE ratio 0.6849 to 0.8247 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.1146 to 0.1310, coverage 0.8940 to 0.9180, SE ratio 0.8297 to 0.8849 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0528 to 0.0638, coverage 0.9078 to 0.9302, SE ratio 0.8994 to 0.9575 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0300 to 0.0386, coverage 0.9224 to 0.9430, SE ratio 0.9391 to 0.9971 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
joint coverage 0.9191 to 0.9458 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0015 to 0.0037, margin 0.0030, RMSE ratio 0.2410 |
||
property |
|
control |
the family’s joint clause |
bias 0.0495 to 0.0511, margin 0.0022, RMSE ratio 0.2410 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
rejection 0.0700, 0.0412 to 0.1095 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9119 to 0.9454, SE ratio 0.8987 to 0.9862 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0010, coverage 0.8965 to 0.9627, SE ratio 0.9892 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.1589 to 0.1660, margin 0.0069, RMSE ratio 1 |
||
property |
|
control |
the family’s joint clause |
bias 0.1589 to 0.1660, margin 0.0069, RMSE ratio 1 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0279 to 0.0443, margin 0.0158, RMSE ratio 0.4415 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0154 to 0.0304, margin 0.0145, RMSE ratio 0.3781 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
rejection 0.0625, 0.0354 to 0.1004 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-sequences |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0032 to 0.0034, coverage 0.9237, SE ratio 0.9051 |
||
property |
|
control |
the family’s joint clause |
bias 0.0494 to 0.0511, margin 0.0023 |
||
property |
|
positive |
the family’s joint clause |
bias -0.0025 to -0.000412, margin 0.0028, RMSE ratio 0.2205, 99% upper 0.2333 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0029 to 0.0051, margin 0.0031, RMSE ratio 0.2542, 99% upper 0.2721 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9267 to 0.9677, SE ratio 0.9694 to 1.1026 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9282 to 0.9688, SE ratio 0.9797 to 1.1151 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.8864 to 0.9385, bias 0.0115 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0026 to 0.0075, margin 0.0067, SE ratio 0.9888 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0068 to 0.0121, margin 0.0072, SE ratio 0.9671 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.8988 to 0.9542, bias 0.000900 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0015 to 0.0072, margin 0.0068, SE ratio 0.9998 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9300 to 0.9597, SE ratio 0.9258 to 1.0123 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias -0.000902, coverage 0.8965 to 0.9627, SE ratio 0.9888 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9287 to 0.9537, SE ratio 0.9294 to 1.0000, empirical efficiency ratio 0.9994 to 1.0751, reported efficiency ratio 0.9980 to 1.0008 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
joint coverage 0.9196 to 0.9462 |
||
observational missing-data DR-TMLE with a composite indicator |
truth |
|
cleverly-composite-drtmle |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0054 to 0.0013, coverage 0.9225, SE ratio 0.9342 |
|
observational missing-data DR-TMLE with a composite indicator |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-composite |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0054 to 0.0013, coverage 0.9237, SE ratio 0.9349 |
|
CV-TMLE of the fold-local learned-rule value at exceptional and weak-blip laws |
truth |
|
cleverly-learned-rule-cvtmle |
its truth gate |
bias -0.000748 to 0.000535, coverage 0.8938, SE ratio 0.8211 |
|
CV-TMLE of the fold-local learned-rule value at exceptional and weak-blip laws |
truth |
|
cleverly-learned-rule-cvtmle |
its truth gate |
bias -0.000514 to 0.000732, coverage 0.8948, SE ratio 0.8314 |
|
paired |
|
paired |
inconclusive: calibration leg |
difference 0.000061 to 0.000361 within 0.000770, RMSE ratio bound 1.0587 vs 1.1000, coverage difference bound -0.0050 vs -0.0250, calibration excess bound 0.0648 vs 0.0500, resolution 0.0439 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9479 to 0.9709, SE ratio 1.0011 to 1.0881, empirical efficiency ratio 0.9208 to 1.0003, reported efficiency ratio 1.0003 to 1.0034 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9187 to 0.9454, SE ratio 0.9263 to 0.9985, empirical efficiency ratio 0.9855 to 1.0615, reported efficiency ratio 0.9783 to 0.9899 |
||
property |
|
positive |
the family’s joint clause |
bias -0.0025 to 0.0019, margin 0.0075 |
||
property |
|
control |
the family’s joint clause |
bias 0.0229 to 0.0284, margin 0.0093 |
||
property |
|
positive |
the family’s joint clause |
bias -0.0027 to 0.0075, margin 0.0172 |
||
property |
|
control |
its own rule |
bias -0.0242 to -0.0148, margin 0.0158 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
rejection 0.0750, 0.0530 to 0.1022 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
rejection 0.5575, 0.5114 to 0.6029 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9289 to 0.9560, SE ratio 0.9432 to 1.0214, empirical efficiency ratio 1.0746 to 1.1643, reported efficiency ratio 1.0948 to 1.1006 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9233 to 0.9467, SE ratio 0.9060 to 0.9775 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-mtp-pricing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.000974 to 0.0024, coverage 0.9160, SE ratio 0.9310 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-mtp-pricing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.000992 to 0.0023, coverage 0.9170, SE ratio 0.9479 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-mtp-pricing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.000981 to 0.0024, coverage 0.9190, SE ratio 0.9339 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-mtp-pricing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.000997 to 0.0023, coverage 0.9230, SE ratio 0.9518 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9530 to 0.9747, SE ratio 1.0265 to 1.1162 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9473 to 0.9704, SE ratio 1.0493 to 1.1408 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9485 to 0.9713, SE ratio 1.0428 to 1.1323 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.000011 to 0.0112, margin 0.0172, coverage 0.8853 to 0.9327, SE ratio 0.9459 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
joint coverage 0.9085 to 0.9394 |
||
longitudinal incremental propensity-score interventions under dropout |
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9491 to 0.9681, SE ratio 1.0124 to 1.0830, empirical efficiency ratio 0.9239 to 0.9884, reported efficiency ratio 1.0005 to 1.0007 |
|
paired |
|
paired |
underpowered: coverage leg, calibration leg, calibration resolution |
difference -0.000150 to 0.000202 within 0.0031, RMSE ratio bound 1.0162 vs 1.1000, coverage difference bound -0.0475 vs -0.0250, calibration excess bound 0.1050 vs 0.0500, resolution 0.1121 |
||
paired |
|
paired |
underpowered: coverage leg, calibration resolution |
difference -0.000350 to 0.000263 within 0.0047, RMSE ratio bound 1.0245 vs 1.1000, coverage difference bound -0.0300 vs -0.0250, calibration excess bound 0.0465 vs 0.0500, resolution 0.0662 |
||
paired |
|
paired |
underpowered: coverage leg, calibration resolution |
difference -0.000118 to 0.000400 within 0.0032, RMSE ratio bound 1.0175 vs 1.1000, coverage difference bound -0.0425 vs -0.0250, calibration excess bound 0.0382 vs 0.0500, resolution 0.1119 |
||
property |
|
control |
its own rule |
bias -0.0251 to -0.0151, margin 0.0167, SE ratio 0.6640 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9232 to 0.9492, SE ratio 0.9430 to 1.0203, empirical efficiency ratio 1.0195 to 1.1006, reported efficiency ratio 1.0333 to 1.0442 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
joint coverage 0.9140 to 0.9283 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9421 to 0.9689, SE ratio 0.9807 to 1.0762, empirical efficiency ratio 0.9300 to 1.0204, reported efficiency ratio 1.0000 to 1.0015 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9421 to 0.9689, SE ratio 0.9650 to 1.0560, empirical efficiency ratio 1.0101 to 1.1085, reported efficiency ratio 1.0592 to 1.0764 |
||
property |
|
control |
its own rule |
bias 0.1306 to 0.1344, margin 0.0175, coverage 0.5072 to 0.5348, SE ratio 0.9970 |
||
property |
|
control |
its own rule |
bias 0.1637 to 0.1682, margin 0.0208, coverage 0.4709 to 0.4984, SE ratio 0.9988 |
||
property |
|
control |
its own rule |
bias 0.1075 to 0.1111, margin 0.0162, coverage 0.5952 to 0.6221, SE ratio 1.0002 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9278 to 0.9529, SE ratio 0.9259 to 1.0000 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0021 to 0.0031, coverage 0.9087, SE ratio 0.8500 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0024 to 0.0013, coverage 0.9025, SE ratio 0.8526 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0019 to 0.0018, coverage 0.9062, SE ratio 0.8463 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0078 to 0.0136, coverage 0.9087, SE ratio 0.8493 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0024 to 0.0036, coverage 0.8875, SE ratio 0.7835 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0013 to 0.0018, coverage 0.8875, SE ratio 0.7859 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0038 to 0.0070, coverage 0.9163, SE ratio 0.8517 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0039 to 0.0030, coverage 0.8888, SE ratio 0.8311 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0039 to 0.0028, coverage 0.9087, SE ratio 0.8631 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0026 to 0.0023, coverage 0.8588, SE ratio 0.7608 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0027 to 0.0022, coverage 0.8738, SE ratio 0.7740 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0148 to 0.0133, coverage 0.8900, SE ratio 0.8329 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0142 to 0.0137, coverage 0.9113, SE ratio 0.8627 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0081 to 0.0072, coverage 0.9000, SE ratio 0.8434 |
||
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0073 to 0.0068, coverage 0.9175, SE ratio 0.8817 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0021 to 0.0031, coverage 0.9087, SE ratio 0.8500 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0024 to 0.0013, coverage 0.9025, SE ratio 0.8526 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0019 to 0.0018, coverage 0.9062, SE ratio 0.8463 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0078 to 0.0136, coverage 0.9087, SE ratio 0.8493 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0024 to 0.0036, coverage 0.8875, SE ratio 0.7835 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0013 to 0.0018, coverage 0.8875, SE ratio 0.7859 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0038 to 0.0070, coverage 0.9163, SE ratio 0.8517 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0039 to 0.0030, coverage 0.8888, SE ratio 0.8311 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0039 to 0.0028, coverage 0.9087, SE ratio 0.8631 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0026 to 0.0023, coverage 0.8588, SE ratio 0.7608 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0027 to 0.0022, coverage 0.8738, SE ratio 0.7740 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0148 to 0.0133, coverage 0.8900, SE ratio 0.8329 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0142 to 0.0137, coverage 0.9113, SE ratio 0.8627 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0081 to 0.0072, coverage 0.9000, SE ratio 0.8434 |
||
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0073 to 0.0068, coverage 0.9175, SE ratio 0.8817 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.8892 to 0.9116, SE ratio 0.8217 to 0.8671 |
||
property |
|
positive |
the family’s joint clause |
coverage 0.9375 to 0.9545, SE ratio 0.9715 to 1.0241 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9085 to 0.9290, SE ratio 0.8674 to 0.9131 |
||
property |
|
positive |
the family’s joint clause |
coverage 0.9413 to 0.9578, SE ratio 0.9836 to 1.0360 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.8820 to 0.9170, SE ratio 0.8202 to 0.8874 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.8842 to 0.9189, SE ratio 0.8081 to 0.8753 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.8863 to 0.9207, SE ratio 0.8060 to 0.8714 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.8928 to 0.9262, SE ratio 0.8509 to 0.9240 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias -0.000434, coverage 0.8786 to 0.9357, SE ratio 0.8636 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.0044, coverage 0.8721 to 0.9308, SE ratio 0.8275 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias -0.000358, coverage 0.8850 to 0.9406, SE ratio 0.8598 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
joint coverage 0.8527 to 0.8883 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
rejection 0.0963, 0.0712 to 0.1262 |
||
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0040 to 0.000874, coverage 0.8750, SE ratio 0.8249 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.000251 to 0.0033, coverage 0.8975, SE ratio 0.8426 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0016 to 0.0016, coverage 0.8738, SE ratio 0.8094 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0152 to 0.0056, coverage 0.8875, SE ratio 0.8237 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0076 to 0.0019, coverage 0.8862, SE ratio 0.8323 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0023 to 0.0031, coverage 0.9012, SE ratio 0.8231 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0017 to 0.0021, coverage 0.9125, SE ratio 0.8751 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0013 to 0.0026, coverage 0.8675, SE ratio 0.7576 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0076 to 0.0158, coverage 0.8950, SE ratio 0.8163 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0041 to 0.0064, coverage 0.9062, SE ratio 0.8453 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.000778 to 0.0033, coverage 0.9187, SE ratio 0.9014 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0013 to 0.0043, coverage 0.9250, SE ratio 0.9175 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0029 to 0.000181, coverage 0.9100, SE ratio 0.8733 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0015 to 0.0012, coverage 0.9038, SE ratio 0.9006 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0024 to 0.0038, coverage 0.9062, SE ratio 0.8510 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0025 to 0.0037, coverage 0.9187, SE ratio 0.9054 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0012 to 0.0033, coverage 0.8575, SE ratio 0.7364 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0015 to 0.0034, coverage 0.8800, SE ratio 0.8012 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0089 to 0.0160, coverage 0.9100, SE ratio 0.8537 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0086 to 0.0172, coverage 0.9187, SE ratio 0.9047 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
cleverly-ctmle-oat-per-arm |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0051 to 0.0084, coverage 0.9137, SE ratio 0.8704 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0040 to 0.000874, coverage 0.8750, SE ratio 0.8248 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.000251 to 0.0033, coverage 0.8975, SE ratio 0.8426 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0016 to 0.0016, coverage 0.8738, SE ratio 0.8094 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0152 to 0.0056, coverage 0.8875, SE ratio 0.8237 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0076 to 0.0019, coverage 0.8862, SE ratio 0.8323 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0023 to 0.0032, coverage 0.9012, SE ratio 0.8231 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0017 to 0.0021, coverage 0.9125, SE ratio 0.8750 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0013 to 0.0026, coverage 0.8675, SE ratio 0.7576 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0076 to 0.0158, coverage 0.8950, SE ratio 0.8163 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0041 to 0.0064, coverage 0.9062, SE ratio 0.8452 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.000772 to 0.0033, coverage 0.9187, SE ratio 0.9013 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0013 to 0.0043, coverage 0.9250, SE ratio 0.9175 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0029 to 0.000176, coverage 0.9100, SE ratio 0.8733 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0015 to 0.0012, coverage 0.9038, SE ratio 0.9006 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0024 to 0.0038, coverage 0.9062, SE ratio 0.8510 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0025 to 0.0037, coverage 0.9187, SE ratio 0.9054 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0012 to 0.0033, coverage 0.8575, SE ratio 0.7364 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0015 to 0.0034, coverage 0.8800, SE ratio 0.8012 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0089 to 0.0160, coverage 0.9100, SE ratio 0.8538 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0086 to 0.0172, coverage 0.9187, SE ratio 0.9046 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
truth |
|
drtmle-r-oat-per-arm-strata-missing |
its truth gate |
bias -0.0051 to 0.0084, coverage 0.9137, SE ratio 0.8704 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.000923, coverage 0.8963 to 0.9460, SE ratio 0.9292 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.000466, coverage 0.8992 to 0.9481, SE ratio 0.8955 |
|
outcome-adaptive per-arm C-TMLE with strata and missing data (point estimates) |
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
bias 0.000447, coverage 0.8949 to 0.9449, SE ratio 0.8812 |
|
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
joint coverage 0.9101 to 0.9382 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
joint coverage 0.9173 to 0.9443 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
joint coverage 0.9015 to 0.9309 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9123 to 0.9342, SE ratio 0.9496 to 1.0065 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9741 to 0.9857, SE ratio 1.2019 to 1.3336 |
||
property |
|
positive |
its own rule |
coverage 0.9730 to 0.9848, SE ratio 1.1663 to 1.3066 |
Reporting studies with no red row#
These studies publish under the reporting policy, and none of them has a red row. The policy
check reads in one direction. A red row needs reporting, but reporting does not need a red
row. A move to gated is a separate registry decision.
study |
verdicts it publishes |
red rows |
|---|---|---|
cross-fitted clustered longitudinal TMLE on a t reference at few clusters |
13 |
0 |
31 |
0 |
|
24 |
0 |
|
29 |
0 |
|
56 |
0 |
|
26 |
0 |
|
47 |
0 |
|
39 |
0 |
|
point-treatment survival, one-step hazard targeting of the curve |
46 |
0 |
24 |
0 |
|
60 |
0 |
|
57 |
0 |
|
55 |
0 |
|
22 |
0 |
|
20 |
0 |
|
298 |
0 |
|
14 |
0 |
|
13 |
0 |